Home > Forum > Fair Pay

Fair Pay

Jan 20, 2024 at 10:33 AM CST
+ 6
New to the forum, learning a lot. Having only shipped LTL for many years I’m interested to hear from the operators what they consider reasonable compensation for bulk loads. Obviously there are a lot of variable and each load is different but on a average what would you consider “FAIR PAY” for your time. If you had your preference would you rather be paid by the mile, by the ton or a flat rate? Not trying to open a can of worms but as a shipper I’m dependent upon operators to move goods. Doesn’t help me to cut y’all off at the knee caps if it ends up making moving stuff across the country a huge pain in the rear end…
Replied on Tue, Jan 23, 2024 at 07:58 AM CST
Wow crickets! As much as y’all complain on pay in other posts I Would have thought I would have gotten something. $50 a ton? $5 a loaded mile? Give me something! 
Replied on Tue, Jan 23, 2024 at 08:08 AM CST
+ 1

In today's economy I'm generally quoting at or near $4.50/mile, plus FSC, plus washout, plus pump if applicable. Of course there is always someone willing to work for free. Truckers are the most profit adverse people I have ever met.

Replied on Tue, Jan 23, 2024 at 08:32 AM CST
+ 1
Tonnage pay is usually best on short hauls. But mile pay plus fsc and wash or flat rate for long loads. I try to get a minimum of 1800 to the truck every day. But i only have 1 truck
Replied on Tue, Jan 23, 2024 at 09:44 AM CST
+ 2
If you can get 1800 per day right now your doing great .
Replied on Tue, Jan 23, 2024 at 09:46 AM CST
+ 2

Travis

In this new world post 2020 we are all on a learning curve, with that being said we would need to find a sustainable win win per ton rate. The reason I mention per ton is in the bulk world it's not fair to you to pay a flat rate & have drivers hauling out of your facilities 23 tons, or your plant oporator loads 26 ton on a truck then expects them to do them to do the work at the same rate.

Next thing we need to look at is the destination, places like Georgia & California will require a higher rate as they are harder areas to get a back haul out.

Take the lane & with your carrier come to a sustainable per mile rate for that lane then convert it to a per ton rate based on 25 tons. I will not bring up per mile or per ton rate here as that is information only shared between the carrier & customer.

If your a shipper then we would like to talk. Thanks hope this helps

Replied on Tue, Jan 23, 2024 at 11:44 AM CST
Quote: "Wow crickets! As much as y’all complain on pay in other posts I Would have thought I would have gotten something. $50 a ton? $5 a loaded mile? Give me something! "

There are crickets due to the lack of information provided.

With bulk, there are too many variables to account for to assess your question fairly. Most good carriers know their break-even and target profitability. They use this to leverage another account against each other to give the best price they can while still making money. Without knowing volumes, lead times, and locations it is impossible to have a fair assessment.

I have a target rate per mile on hub miles broken down for every trailer in my fleet, hopper, belt, tanker, and van. This target rate varied by lanes depending on other known customers and our ability to leverage those relationships. I can offer loads with longer lead times at a lower rate since it gives me time to plan. Day-specific versus week-specific fall into two more categories. Then one-off loads versus 100 loads to the same location reflect different prices. Then there are developed customers versus new customers.

Then there is the fact that everyone's break-even will be different. What works for us might not work for others. Or others might be able to run for less than we can.

Instead of looking for blanket statements perhaps narrow in on your target market and get feedback there.

Replied on Tue, Jan 23, 2024 at 01:15 PM CST

Since everyone's cost of doing business is different, you will get a different response from everyone. In this line of work you have to look at where the load rich areas of the country are and aren't. It's all about the flow of commodities. If you really want an idea where rates are just post a (legit) lane and have carriers bid on it.

Replied on Tue, Jan 23, 2024 at 08:21 PM CST

I think in the trucking industry in general, there's no way to have a "uniform" way of things when it comes to pay, how to pay etc. I think you need to start asking more along the lines of where are the dead zones, what product comes in and out of an area, it is seasonal or yearly, could it be a product that not many drivers will haul, etc. Example - took a load of lava rock which paid decent but it destroyed my trailer. I think it more on how it was loaded. Anyway, once you learn that, in which I'm still learning too, then you can start getting a little closer as to what to pay.

Replied on Wed, Jan 24, 2024 at 07:45 AM CST
All fair points. The variable faced by individual haulers as well as fleet haulers appear to be numerous and very specific. Also the location of pickup and drop off clearly are a factor in price as well. Thank you for the education.
Replied on Thu, Jan 25, 2024 at 07:03 AM CST
+ 1
Quote: "All fair points. The variable faced by individual haulers as well as fleet haulers appear to be numerous and very specific. Also the location of pickup and drop off clearly are a factor in price as well. Thank you for the education."

You didn't identify the specific equipment needed. Net pay load varies. Hoppers will net roughly 26 ton. Walking floors will net roughly 23 ton. Etc, Etc.

Replied on Thu, Jan 25, 2024 at 07:50 AM CST
+ 2

The bulk market is unike any other market. Rates can vary. We base all of our pricing on 25 ton for hopper bottoms. We use 22 ton as a base for walking floor trailers. Our questions that we ask a potential customer are:

What is the product?

Where is the origin?

What is destination?

What are loading and unlaoding hours?

We cant really put a competitve price on a product without knowing that information.

Replied on Thu, Jan 25, 2024 at 10:15 AM CST
Quote: "The bulk market is unike any other market. Rates can vary. We base all of our pricing on 25 ton for hopper bottoms. We use 22 ton as a base for walking floor trailers. Our questions that we ask a potential customer are: What is the product? Where is the origin? What is destination? What are loading and unlaoding hours? We cant really put a competitve price on a product without knowing that information."

I agree bulk is not like any other. I did forget in bulk you're basically hauling products in its rawest form. Some areas mother nature can play a roll too. You gotta look at what areas have cheap rates. Like California and Florida. In my experience both states pay good going in but horrible coming out. I pulled flatbed many moons ago and its still like that. There's A LOT of variants in the bulk side of trucking. We've gone to private farmers to load/unload products and some places dont even have scales. Its going to keep you on your toes and it changes daily.

Replied on Wed, Jan 31, 2024 at 04:32 PM CST

$7 - 8/loaded mile on a 44 - 46 tonne load

Replied on Wed, Jan 31, 2024 at 04:32 PM CST
Quote: "I agree bulk is not like any other. I did forget in bulk you're basically hauling products in its rawest form. Some areas mother nature can play a roll too. You gotta look at what areas have cheap rates. Like California and Florida. In my experience both states pay good going in but horrible coming out. I pulled flatbed many moons ago and its still like that. There's A LOT of variants in the bulk side of trucking. We've gone to private farmers to load/unload products and some places dont even have scales. Its going to keep you on your toes and it changes daily. "

sorry to burst yer bubble but all freight rates are dependant on the commodity contracts signed before you even get contacted to move it and the freight the buyer or shippers have built into the contract determines that rate. you can always tell by the price they offer.

Replied on Sat, Feb 03, 2024 at 12:04 PM CST

Anyone here haul food grade flour? I was considering buying a food grade trailer, but the rate I was offered seemed really low. No washout pay, no fuel surcharge and less than 5 a mile one way. Normally I haul powdered cement, limestone, salt etc and do well. Are food grade rates always that low?,

Replied on Sat, Feb 03, 2024 at 12:05 PM CST
+ 2 - 1
Quote: "sorry to burst yer bubble but all freight rates are dependant on the commodity contracts signed before you even get contacted to move it and the freight the buyer or shippers have built into the contract determines that rate. you can always tell by the price they offer."

Sometimes it doesn't matter what a customer WANTS to pay, or what a contract says. Sometimes the ALL miles pay just don't add up and a load sits. If I'm asked to haul a load for a low rate, I just tell the broker/shipper the price that works for me..... often times when a rate is too low for me, it's too low for others as well.

With companies like Prime Inc getting into the bulk game, I believe we will or SHOULD BE a little less forthcoming on rates we are willing to run for. Let em find out the hard way.